A Presidential Pardon Cannot Protect Wrongdoers from Civil Accountability
The President of the United States possesses virtually unlimited constitutional authority to pardon individuals who have committed federal crimes. A President may even pardon a person before criminal charges have been brought. But civil liability cannot be pardoned. The Constitution does not give the President the power to extinguish the civil claims of people injured by unlawful conduct. The Supreme Court recognized this distinction more than 160 years ago in Ex parte Garland, 71 U.S. 333 (1866).
Civil liability does not require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. In most civil actions, liability can be established by a preponderance of the evidence, including circumstantial evidence. Criminal conduct that has been pardoned may nevertheless support a civil judgment.
Follow the Wrongdoing to the Wrongdoers
Investigation of government corruption should begin with the individuals who carried out the unlawful acts, those who facilitated them, and those who profited from them.
Individuals who knowingly participate in unlawful activities may face personal civil liability for their conduct. Investigations of organized criminal enterprises have repeatedly demonstrated the importance of examining the activities of participants at every level and following the evidence wherever it leads.
Individuals facing substantial personal financial liability may have compelling reasons to disclose information about the transactions, communications, and decisions in which they participated.
Congress Can Expose the Facts. The States and Private Citizens Can Act.
Congressional committees can conduct hearings, issue subpoenas, demand records, question witnesses, and investigate the expenditure of public funds and the conduct of government officials. Congressional investigations can identify those who participated in unlawful activities and uncover evidence supporting civil actions against them.
Every state possesses its own legal system, courts, and laws governing fraud, unlawful financial conduct, and other forms of civil wrongdoing. State attorneys general can investigate suspected violations of applicable state laws and bring civil enforcement proceedings against those responsible.
Individuals, businesses, nonprofit organizations, and other entities injured by unlawful conduct may also bring civil actions against those responsible. Groups of injured persons may pursue class actions where authorized by law.
Investigative Reporters Have an Essential Role
Investigative journalism has repeatedly exposed corruption, financial misconduct, abuses of public authority, and relationships that powerful individuals sought to conceal. By examining public records, financial transactions, government contracts, and firsthand accounts, investigative reporters can identify participants, uncover previously concealed activities, and expose wrongdoing that government officials have failed or refused to investigate.
The Time for Accountability Is Now
Congress should immediately assemble the evidence of government corruption, identify those who participated in or facilitated it, and make its findings public. State attorneys general and public interest organizations should then begin pursuing civil actions against the wrongdoers identified without delay.
Accountability begins when those entrusted with these powers use them.
Civil Liability Cannot Be Pardoned
November 16, 2026 | Constitutional Law
A Presidential Pardon Cannot Protect Wrongdoers from Civil Accountability
The President of the United States possesses virtually unlimited constitutional authority to pardon individuals who have committed federal crimes. A President may even pardon a person before criminal charges have been brought. But civil liability cannot be pardoned. The Constitution does not give the President the power to extinguish the civil claims of people injured by unlawful conduct. The Supreme Court recognized this distinction more than 160 years ago in Ex parte Garland, 71 U.S. 333 (1866).
Civil liability does not require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. In most civil actions, liability can be established by a preponderance of the evidence, including circumstantial evidence. Criminal conduct that has been pardoned may nevertheless support a civil judgment.
Follow the Wrongdoing to the Wrongdoers
Investigation of government corruption should begin with the individuals who carried out the unlawful acts, those who facilitated them, and those who profited from them.
Individuals who knowingly participate in unlawful activities may face personal civil liability for their conduct. Investigations of organized criminal enterprises have repeatedly demonstrated the importance of examining the activities of participants at every level and following the evidence wherever it leads.
Individuals facing substantial personal financial liability may have compelling reasons to disclose information about the transactions, communications, and decisions in which they participated.
Congress Can Expose the Facts. The States and Private Citizens Can Act.
Congressional committees can conduct hearings, issue subpoenas, demand records, question witnesses, and investigate the expenditure of public funds and the conduct of government officials. Congressional investigations can identify those who participated in unlawful activities and uncover evidence supporting civil actions against them.
Every state possesses its own legal system, courts, and laws governing fraud, unlawful financial conduct, and other forms of civil wrongdoing. State attorneys general can investigate suspected violations of applicable state laws and bring civil enforcement proceedings against those responsible.
Individuals, businesses, nonprofit organizations, and other entities injured by unlawful conduct may also bring civil actions against those responsible. Groups of injured persons may pursue class actions where authorized by law.
Investigative Reporters Have an Essential Role
Investigative journalism has repeatedly exposed corruption, financial misconduct, abuses of public authority, and relationships that powerful individuals sought to conceal. By examining public records, financial transactions, government contracts, and firsthand accounts, investigative reporters can identify participants, uncover previously concealed activities, and expose wrongdoing that government officials have failed or refused to investigate.
The Time for Accountability Is Now
Congress should immediately assemble the evidence of government corruption, identify those who participated in or facilitated it, and make its findings public. State attorneys general and public interest organizations should then begin pursuing civil actions against the wrongdoers identified without delay.
Accountability begins when those entrusted with these powers use them.