🇺🇸 +1-516-551-0764 ✉ barrister@yannalaw.com
AboutEssaysCommentaryServicesContact

Americans Need Healthcare Not Health Insurance

Congress Is Trying to Solve the Wrong Problem

    Physician providing medical care to a patient — healthcare, not health insurance

Physician providing medical care to a patient — healthcare, not health insurance

Health insurance is not a solution to the American healthcare problem. It is the problem.

Americans need healthcare, not health insurance, but for decades, Congress and successive administrations have concentrated on the cost of health insurance premiums, the availability of health insurance policies, government subsidies for insurance companies, employer-sponsored insurance, deductibles, copayments, and the number of Americans who have health insurance coverage.

Congress continues searching for ways to help Americans pay for health insurance when it should be concentrating on ensuring that every American receives the medical care and treatment they need.

A person suffering a heart attack does not need an insurance policy. They need a physician, nurses, emergency medical facilities, diagnostic equipment, medications, and whatever treatment is medically necessary to preserve their life.

A child with leukemia does not need an insurance company. They need qualified physicians, appropriate medications, laboratory services, and continuing medical treatment.

Someone who requires surgery needs a surgeon, an anesthesiologist, nurses, an operating room, and appropriate postoperative care.

Insurance companies provide none of these medical services. They do not diagnose illness, perform operations, administer medications, or care for patients. They collect money, administer insurance contracts, and determine what medical expenses they will pay for or refuse to pay.

According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Americans spent approximately $5.279 trillion on healthcare in 2024, representing 18 percent of the nation’s gross domestic product and amounting to approximately $15,474 for every man, woman, and child in the United States.

We already have a system for paying healthcare providers directly

The federal government has been financing medical care through Medicare since 1965.

Traditional Medicare, as distinguished from privately administered Medicare Advantage plans, provides an established system for identifying eligible patients, recognizing qualified healthcare providers, processing claims, establishing payment amounts, and compensating physicians and medical facilities.

The question is why this established system should not become available to every American.

The cost of maintaining the health insurance industry

Health insurance companies maintain administrative organizations, executive management, claims departments, underwriting operations, computer systems, marketing activities, and other corporate functions. Physicians, hospitals, and other healthcare providers must maintain their own administrative systems to communicate with those insurance companies and comply with their requirements.

The American Medical Association’s 2025 survey of physicians reported that medical practices completed an average of approximately 40 prior authorization requests per physician each week. Physicians and their employees spent an average of 13 hours weekly handling those requests. Forty percent of responding physicians reported that their practices employed personnel who worked exclusively on prior authorization.

These are hours devoted to obtaining permission from organizations responsible for paying medical bills, rather than examining patients, performing surgery, interpreting diagnostic tests, or administering treatment.

The same survey found that 95 percent of responding physicians reported that prior authorization delayed access to necessary care.

The question Congress should be asking is why healthcare professionals must devote so much time to dealing with insurance companies in the first place.

Subsidizing health insurance is not the same asd financing healthcare

Instead of appropriating public funds to help individuals purchase health insurance policies, Congress should establish a system in which medically necessary treatment is financed as a public service and appropriate the funds to pay for it.

Access to necessary medical care and treatment should not depend on employment status or the terms of an insurance contract.

Private insurance could remain available for individuals who voluntarily wish to purchase coverage for services outside the universal program, such as elective cosmetic procedures or other treatments not included in publicly financed medical care.

Stop financing health insurance and start financing healthcare

The purpose of American healthcare policy must be to ensure that every American receives the medical care and treatment they need.

Americans need healthcare, not health insurance.